FREE SHIPPING ON ALL US ORDERS $50+
New: Subscribe & Save Up To 15% >

Everything Except Foundation

Puzzle Makeup The Overachiever 2-in-1 tinted moisturizer and foundation in pump bottle on light gray background
Moonflower - Light Redness Jasmine - Moderate Redness Pearl Quartz - Severe Redness +12
NEW
$42.00
The Overachiever 2-In-1 For Rosacea
show options
Face Powder in White Rose - Rosacea To Fair – vegan, long lasting, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
White Rose - Rosacea To Fair Daisy - Fair To Light Madeleine - Light To Medium +9
Subscribe & Save
$32.00
Face Powder
show options
Puzzle Makeup The Overachiever 2-in-1 tinted moisturizer and foundation in pump bottle on light gray background
Moonflower - Light Redness Jasmine - Moderate Redness Pearl Quartz - Severe Redness +12
Subscribe & Save
$42.00
The Overachiever 2-In-1
show options
Linen Lip Stain – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Linen Magnolia Morning Glory +14
$23.00
Lip Stain
show options
Puzzle Makeup The Overachiever 2-in-1 tinted moisturizer and foundation in pump bottle on light gray background
Moonflower - Light Redness Jasmine - Moderate Redness Pearl Quartz - Severe Redness +13
NEW
From $18.00
The Overachiever 2-In-1 Samples
show options
Meringue Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Meringue Swan Pearlstone +54
$22.50
Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
show options
$52.00
The Overachiever 2-In-1 Custom Blend
Puzzle Makeup Powder Brush - vegan soft powder brush for smooth, even application and blending
$29.00
Powder Brush
Wildflower Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Wildflower Freesia Peach Lily +18
$25.00
Blush
show options
Puzzle Makeup Latex Free Wedge Sponge - vegan makeup applicator for precise blending and even coverage
$3.00
Latex Free Wedge Sponge
Driftwood Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Driftwood Pampas Lilac +17
$22.50
Matte Pressed Eyeshadow
show options
Coral Reef Lip Gloss – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Coral Reef Prosecco Rosé +23
$23.00
Lip Gloss Wand
show options
Arabella Lipstick – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Arabella Meadowsweet Carnation +2
$25.00
Satin Lipstick
show options
Puzzle Makeup Small Magnetic Palette filled with colorful eyeshadow pans – refillable vegan customizable makeup palette
$14.00
Empty Magnetic Palette Small
Vicious Trollop Lip Gloss – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Vicious Trollop - Lip Gloss Wand
Alabaster highlighter – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Alabaster White Lotus Opal Glow +5
$27.00
Highlighter
show options
Puzzle Makeup Blush and Highlighter Brush close-up - soft vegan bristles for seamless blush and highlight application
$26.00
Blush, Bronzer and Highlighter Brush
Puzzle Makeup Large Magnetic Palette filled with blushes, powders, and eyeshadows – refillable vegan customizable makeup palette
$16.00
Empty Magnetic Palette Large
Terrene Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Terrene Topaz Sunrise +4
$27.00
Bronzer
show options
Puzzle Makeup Makeup Remover bottle – gentle vegan cleanser that hydrates and soothes skin
3 in stock
$12.00
Makeup Remover
$23.00
Cherry Blossom - Lip Stain
$32.00
Daisy - Face Powder
Puzzle Makeup Medium Eyeshadow Brush - vegan blending brush for eyelid, crease, and brow bone application
$19.00
Medium Eyeshadow Brush
Peridot Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Peridot - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Puzzle Makeup Large Eyeshadow Brush - vegan blending brush for smooth, even eyeshadow application
$20.00
Large/Blending Eyeshadow Brush
Puzzle Makeup Angled Brush - vegan precision tool for eyeliner, corner shadow, and smudging
$16.00
Angled Brush
204 results

Custom
MAKEUP QUIZ

NOT SURE WHERE TO START?

Take our 1-minute quiz to get personalized shade recommendations. Professionally selected based on real skin, real routines, and your unique needs.

take the quiz