FREE SHIPPING ON ALL US ORDERS $50+
New: Subscribe & Save Up To 15% >

The Overachiever 2-In-1 Custom Blend

The Overachiever 2-In-1 Custom Blend

TINTED MOISTURIZER X FOUNDATION

$52.00

For the most accurate match, upload a selfie in natural light with clean, bare skin. Your photo is used only to custom blend your shade and is kept completely private, never shared.

Example selfie for shade matching Example of a clear selfie
Formulated By A Licensed Esthetician
Silicone And Fragrance Free
Shade Match Guarantee: Free Exchange or Easy Return
Free Shipping On Orders $50+
Made In The U.S.
Description

<p style="margin-bottom:16px;">The Overachiever custom shade, mixed for you. Same 2-in-1 formula blended to your skin tone.</p>

<p>One layer delivers sheer, breathable hydration with a natural tint; two layers build to smooth, foundation-level coverage. Skincare-infused and non-comedogenic, it supports evolving skin while leaving a fresh, radiant finish that looks like your skin, only better.</p>

How To Use

If you want your custom blend foundation to stay all day without extra touch-ups, use this professional application technique:
<ul>
<li>Why Apply Foundation With A Face Sponge
<ul>
<li>A makeup sponge creates a thinner and softer application while also staying true to the original foundation color. Foundation applied by a blending sponge stays in place for much longer resulting in a smoother and more even texture.</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li>How to Apply Foundation With A Face Sponge
<ul>
<li>To make the formula naturally thicker you will need to use the thin side of the sponge. To make the formula a sheer finish you will need to use the thick side of the sponge.</li>
<li>Apply foundation using the wedge sponge in soft strokes (not dabbing) all over your face and eyelids.</li>
<li>Apply from the center of the forehead outwards towards temples. Repeat on other side from center to temple. Then repeat this makeup application (from inside to outside) all the way down to the chin.</li>
<li>After, for long-lasting and clean results, apply your Pressed Powder all over your face and eyelids with a powder brush. Remember to use the body of the brush (not the head of the brush) in soft strokes.</li>
<li>Here are some professional tutorials to guide you:
<ul>
<li>
<a href="https://puzzlemakeup.com/blogs/tutorial/foundation-applications-stroking-vs-dabbing-puzzle-makeup">https://puzzlemakeup.com/blogs/tutorial/foundation-applications-stroking-vs-dabbing-puzzle-makeup</a>
</li>
<li>
<a href="https://puzzlemakeup.com/blogs/tutorial/foundation-powder-application">https://puzzlemakeup.com/blogs/tutorial/foundation-powder-application</a>
</li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>

Ingredients benefits

<p>Every Puzzle product is infused with skin-loving ingredients, but this 2-in-1 is an absolute skincare powerhouse. It boosts hydration and strengthens the skin barrier, supports collagen and elasticity for healthier-looking skin, brightens and evens tone for a radiant complexion, and delivers lightweight, breathable wear that feels comfortable all day.</p>

<ul>
<li><strong>Plant-based oils &amp; fatty acids:</strong> hydrate, soften, and support elasticity with lightweight, non-comedogenic moisture.</li>
<li><strong>Pomegranate extract:</strong> rich in vitamin C and polyphenols to brighten, even tone, and support collagen.</li>
<li><strong>Tea extracts (white, green &amp; black):</strong> antioxidant-rich botanicals that defend against free radicals, soothe sensitivity, and help maintain firmness.</li>
<li><strong>Vitamin E:</strong> protects from environmental damage, locks in moisture, and softens the look of fine lines.</li>
<li><strong>Sugarcane-derived emollients:</strong> deliver a silky, breathable texture that hydrates without heaviness.</li>
<li><strong>Performance-enhancing naturals:</strong> coconut- and corn-derived emulsifiers blend seamlessly, while mineral-based powders improve spreadability, absorb excess oil, and create a smooth, soft-focus finish.</li>
</ul>

Full Ingredients List

Water (Aqua), Dicaprylyl Carbonate, Polyglyceryl-2-Dipolyhydroxystearate, Hexyl Laurate, Mica, Butylene Glycol, Polyglyceryl-3-Diisostearate, Undecane, Propanediol, Pentaerythrityl Distearate, Sodium Chloride, Boron Nitride, Stearalkonium Hectorite, Potassium Cetyl Phosphate, Tridecane, Hydroxyacetophenone, Propylene Carbonate, Tocopheryl Acetate (vitamin E), Niacinamide, Lauroyl Lysine, Sodium Hyaluronate, Glycerin, Punica Granatum (Pomegranate) Extract, Camellia Sinensis (White Tea) Leaf Extract. May Contain: Iron Oxide CI 77492, Titanium Dioxide CI 77891, Iron Oxide CI 77499, Iron Oxide CI 77491, Chromium Hydroxide Green Cl 77289, Ultramarine Blue CI 77007.

✓ 100% Clean  ✓ Vegan  ✓ Multi-Use  ✓ Ideal For Mature Skin  ✓ Buildable  ✓ Lightweight  ✓ Long-Lasting  ✓ Skincare Benefits  ✓ Silicon-Free  ✓ Paraben-Free  ✓ Cruelty-Free  ✓ Fragrance-Free

YOUR REAL RESULTS WITH

The OVERACHIEVER

“
I have spent twenty-three years working on rosacea-prone skin. I watched my clients struggle to find anything that let their skin look like skin: full-coverage foundations that sat on them like a mask or made them look ashy, and products labeled for sensitive skin that still turned their faces red. They arrived defeated.

I was not willing to let the people who need the most care be the ones the industry ignored. So I put the correction into the formula itself, because rosacea does not give you the same face two days in a row. Skin always comes first.
”
Avital Signature

Avital Elgaziel

PUZZLE FOUNDER, EXPERT ESTHETICIAN & MAKEUP ARTIST

Avital Elgaziel
video

Powerhouse INGREDIENTS

NIACINAMIDE(SCREENED FOR NO RESIDUAL NICOTINIC ACID)

Redness Support + Tone Evening

Plant-Based Oils & Fatty Acids

Lightweight Hydration + Elasticity Support

Pomegranate Extract

Brightens Tone + Supports Collagen

Tea Extracts

Antioxidant Protection + Calming Care

Vitamin E

Barrier Protection + Moisture Retention

Sugarcane-Derived Emollients

Silky, Breathable Hydration

For A Tinted Moisturizer Finish

(Sheer, Skin-Like Coverage)

Dispense a small amount (one pump or dime-sized) and apply one layer with your fingers, or for best results, use the Latex-Free Wedge Sponge. Blend outward from the center of your face using gentle stroking motions. Allow the formula to set for a few seconds - the shade will adjust to its true tone.

For A Foundation Finish

(Buildable Coverage)

Let the first layer settle for 30–60 seconds, then gently apply a second layer throughout. Allow it to set for a few seconds, and the shade will fully adjust.

Avital's Pro Tip

Use gentle stroking motions for a flawless, even finish. Start with less product and build as needed. Pair with Puzzle Pressed Powder for a more polished, long-lasting result.

Sponge Guide

Thin side → thicker appearance. Thick side → thinner appearance.

Love For THE OVERACHIEVER

"I must confess, this is by far the best makeup I have ever used! I have tried every brand name to drug store brand, this stuff is amazing. It covers all my red and doesn't turn orange or run off by the afternoon."

— Denise B.

"I am in my 60s and have mild rosacea with several broken capillaries. I have tried dozens of foundations, spent hundreds of dollars and they covered my rosacea and red spots, but made my face look like pebbles everywhere showing my large pores. I'm shocked, amazed, pleased with the Puzzle overachiever. The color blends right in naturally, it doesn't sink into my pores or wrinkles and it neutralizes the pink tone to my skin. I highly recommend this product and I am NOT being compensated for this post. My honest opinion."

— Joanna S.

"These are the first base products I've used that truly cover up my redness without making me look like a zombie, Cheeto, or like a chalky ghost, and without irritating my skin! As someone who is very very fair but has rosacea, finding a base product is extremely difficult. Most are too yellow/orange, emphasize my redness or even worse make me look dead."

— Dana

“I am so excited about this product! I have very sensitive skin that is prone to redness/inflammation/rosacea so I've always shied away from foundation for fear of irritating my skin. I gave this product a try since it is also a moisturizer and I couldn't be happier with it. It actually feels good on my skin while also giving enough coverage to even out the redness. And it lasts all day, amazing!”

— Emily

“I'm an outdoors type of woman, very active and not into heavy makeup. I have a lot of red undertones and have tried all sorts of foundations from department stores and Sephora, trying to find a light foundation to even out my skin. Then I found Avital and Puzzle Makeup! Avital mixes my foundation exactly to fit my skin color and keeps the redness under control for the entire day. It's perfect! I highly recommend making a consultation appointment with Avital and letting her work her magic on you, too. You'll love your look!”

— Susan

“After trying SO many tinted moisturizers and foundations, I've finally found THE ONE. I have combination skin and have struggled to find something that's not too matte and looks dewy without getting greasy — this totally nails it. One light layer is perfect for everyday when I just want a natural, healthy glow with light coverage (while effectively evening skin tone, mind you), and two layers build into full coverage for more polished occasions without ever feeling cakey. It wears beautifully! Avital custom-matched my color, and I was a little skeptical at first as it looked a bit gray before applying, but it's actually the PERFECT shade.”

— Kat

“When I say I've tried a LOT of tinted moisturizers, I mean it. For 20+ years, it's been one of two things you're sure to find in my makeup bag (mascara = #2). I rate them on 1) how clean the ingredients are, 2) how they feel on my skin, and 3) how they look. The Overachiever checks all my boxes and then some. I just love that I can swipe on a single layer for everyday wear and put on a second layer for more coverage - both ways it feels and looks great. Add in Puzzle's mission and story, and what's not to love?”

— Lauren

“Puzzle custom-mixed foundation is amazing! It is blended to match perfectly with your unique skin tone, and it provides great coverage. Since my skin is acne-prone, I really appreciate that the foundation is clean and doesn't cause breakouts or irritation. I highly recommend it!”

— Aviva

“I've worn the same high-end department store foundation for years. I had no problem with it, but my friend suggested I try Puzzle Makeup. I thought I would give it a try. I'm not a fan of the "mineral makeup" that was popular for a while. I found it too drying and dull on my skin. Puzzle foundation is amazingly light, creamy, and gives a beautiful luminescence to the skin. They will mix it up just for you and can match it exactly to your skin tone. The face powder also feels so good on my skin and creates a beautiful finish. Love it! I won't go back.”

— Annette

“Puzzle Makeup has completely changed the way I feel about wearing makeup. I've been amazed at how effortlessly the foundation blends into my skin, enhancing my natural beauty instead of covering it up. The formula feels incredibly light, like I'm wearing nothing at all - yet the results are flawless. I've never had so many compliments on my complexion! I'm officially obsessed.”

— Laura

Overall rating: 4.911111 / 5 from 90 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

This foundation offers a flawless, natural finish with long-lasting, breathable coverage. It is crafted from organic ingredients, is oil-free, and provides a smooth, non-comedogenic feel. Customers appreciate its clean, natural look and the ability to customize their shade for a perfect match.

Summary topics

  • Coverage (20%): A significant number of customers raved about how the product provides great coverage without looking too heavy or thick.
  • Makeup Quality (20%): Many customers remarked that they loved the makeup and found it to be clean and natural-looking.
  • Skin Look (22%): A significant number of customers appreciated how the product made their skin look smooth and natural on their skin.
  • Skin Compatibility (18%): A significant amount of customers expressed satisfaction with the non-toxic, oil-free, and noncomedogenic foundation.

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

  • "Now after I wash my face, my skin feels so soft and hydrated - it's amazing!" — Karan H.
  • "Puzzle foundation is amazingly light, creamy, and gives a beautiful luminescence to the skin." — Annette
  • "It is blended to match perfectly with your unique skin tone, it provides great coverage." — Aviva

Reviews

Surprisingly good

"I bought the lightest shade to help with my perimenopausal skin that's a combination of rosacea and random crabbiness. The color is almost grayish green so I was sceptical as I have very pale, cool toned skin. But spreading it on, it worked it. It tamped down the redness but didn't look obvious. It doesn't irritate my skin and I will purchase it again. The finish is lightly dewy without looking greasy."

— Cynthia H. (5/5)

The perfect combination helps reduce flares.

"Not only covered my rosesa but also seemed to reduce the flares! I felt a bit washed out with just the Puzzle but customer service assistance solved that concern with perfect powder recommendation. Extremely happy with both products!"

— Vickie L. (5/5)

Reduces inflammation & blends well

"Puzzle The Overachiever not only covers redness though reduces redness over a few weeks. I use it on my cheeks, chin and nose only and it blends in my skin color, looking natural. I absolutely love this product, and highly recommend it. I use moonflower for light redness."

— Melinda (5/5)

Very happy

"Love the way this feels on my skin! It covers redness well and leaves my skin feeling moisturized all day. The color blend is perfect!"

— Ashley H. (5/5)

Coverage and color match are

"Coverage and color match are awesome. Holds up well with sweating. Love that when I bought 2, I got a free powder and brush."

— Ann S. (5/5)

Good choice

"I was skeptical but now I’m pleasantly surprised. Color was perfect, calmed the redness in my skin, didn’t look flaky. I will now purchase the full size."

— Cynthia D. (5/5)

Love the way it covers,

"Love the way it covers, but does look a bit grey on my skin. Don’t like the pump dispenser. It took many, many pumps to get any makeup out. Still difficult to work and splatters when pumped."

— Thomas G. (4/5)

Holy Grail of skincare/foundation

"My face is not burning or breaking out in rosacea since I started using 2 weeks ago. I feel my skin barrier is not being compromised and restoring itself to be more calm and less reactive."

— Victoria C. (5/5)

Excellent customer service and outstanding product

"I am so pleased to clear my makeup stash of cc creams and foundations that are the wrong shade, seem to leave my skin red and irritated or make my face look like it is made of stucco. The custom blend covers my rosacea and looks like my skin without the need for heavy layers."

— Sheridan (5/5)

Gave me hope

"This has been a wonderful experience. My skin isn't perfect but nothing really ever is, but WOW has it calmed down significantly. I am in love with this stuff. I highly recommend feels cool soft and luxurious when applied. You won't regret it!"

— ERICA H. (5/5)

Q&A

Join Us → @PUZZLEMAKEUP

Everyday routines, visible results, pro tips from Avital, and a community that gets it.