FREE SHIPPING ON ALL US ORDERS $50+
New: Subscribe & Save Up To 15% >

Products

1:1 with Avital – Already Placed an Order – personalized follow-up consultation for product tips and tutorials
$50.00
1-On-1 With Avital: Already Placed An Order?
1:1 with Avital – New to Puzzle – personalized beauty consultation to find your perfect makeup routine
$75.00
1-On-1 With Avital: New To Puzzle?
Alabaster highlighter – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$27.00
Alabaster - Highlighter
Amaranth Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Amaranth - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Amarena Lipstick – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$25.00
Amarena - Satin Lipstick
Amethyst Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Amethyst - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Puzzle Makeup Angled Brush - vegan precision tool for eyeliner, corner shadow, and smudging
$16.00
Angled Brush
Aquamarine Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Aquamarine - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Arabella Lipstick – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$25.00
Arabella - Satin Lipstick
Aurora Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Aurora - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Azalea Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$25.00
Azalea - Blush
Azure Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Azure - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Barolo Lip Gloss – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Barolo - Lip Gloss Wand
Begonia Lip Stain – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Begonia - Lip Stain
Black Cherry Lip Stain – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Black Cherry - Lip Stain
Bloom Lip Stain – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Bloom - Lip Stain
Wildflower Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Wildflower Freesia Peach Lily +18
$25.00
Blush
show options
Puzzle Makeup Blush and Highlighter Brush close-up - soft vegan bristles for seamless blush and highlight application
$26.00
Blush, Bronzer and Highlighter Brush
Lip Gloss – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Bordeaux - Lip Gloss Wand
Terrene Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
Terrene Topaz Sunrise +4
$27.00
Bronzer
show options
Bronzite Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$27.00
Bronzite - Bronzer
Buttercream Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Buttercream - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Cabernet Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Cabernet - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Camellia Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$25.00
Camellia - Blush
Canary Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Canary - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Canyon Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$25.00
Canyon - Blush
204 results

Custom
MAKEUP QUIZ

NOT SURE WHERE TO START?

Take our 1-minute quiz to get personalized shade recommendations. Professionally selected based on real skin, real routines, and your unique needs.

take the quiz