FREE SHIPPING ON ALL US ORDERS $50+
New: Subscribe & Save Up To 15% >

Fan Favorites

Vicious Trollop Lip Gloss – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Vicious Trollop - Lip Gloss Wand
Foxglove Lip Gloss – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Foxglove - Lip Gloss Wand
Cinnamon Lip Stain – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Cinnamon - Lip Stain
Merlot Lip Stain – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$23.00
Merlot - Lip Stain
Smoky Quartz Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Smoky Quartz - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Galaxy Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Galaxy - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Rose Quartz Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Rose Quartz - Glow Pressed Eyeshadow
Coffee Bean Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Coffee Bean - Matte Pressed Eyeshadow
Sage Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Sage - Matte Pressed Eyeshadow
Lilac Pressed Eyeshadow – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$22.50
Lilac - Matte Pressed Eyeshadow
Terracotta Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$25.00
Terracotta - Blush
Rose Mist Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$25.00
Rose Mist - Blush
Topaz Blush – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$27.00
Topaz - Bronzer
Champagne highlighter – vegan, buildable, blendable, multiuse, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
$27.00
Champagne - Highlighter
Puzzle Makeup Essential Brush Set - eight-piece vegan brush set
$163.00
The Essential Brush Set
Puzzle Makeup Small Magnetic Palette filled with colorful eyeshadow pans – refillable vegan customizable makeup palette
$14.00
Empty Magnetic Palette Small