FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OVER $50
Puzzle Makeup The Overachiever 2-in-1 tinted moisturizer and foundation in pump bottle on light gray background
Beige makeup swatch on a light gray background
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Pearl Quartz – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Rose Opal – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Gardenia – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Seashore – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Sun Kiss – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Summer Day – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Latte – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Hazelnut – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Spiced Cocoa – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Cacao – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Espresso – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Mahogany – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Obsidian – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup

The Overachiever 2-in-1 Tinted Moisturizer X Foundation Samples

Puzzle Makeup The Overachiever 2-in-1 tinted moisturizer and foundation in pump bottle on light gray background
Beige makeup swatch on a light gray background
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Pearl Quartz – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Rose Opal – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Gardenia – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Seashore – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Sun Kiss – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Summer Day – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Latte – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Hazelnut – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Spiced Cocoa – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Cacao – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Espresso – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Mahogany – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup
The Overachiever tinted moisturizer and foundation swatch in Obsidian – vegan, buildable, skin-loving formula by Puzzle Makeup

The Overachiever 2-in-1 Tinted Moisturizer X Foundation Samples

$15.00
: Cacao - Dark To Deep
Formulated By A Licensed Esthetician
Silicone And Fragrance Free
Shade Match Guarantee: Free Exchange or Easy Return
Free Shipping On Orders $50+
Made In The U.S.
Description

<p style="margin-bottom:16px;">Trial size, not a full bottle. Order your shade to test the match on your skin, then size up once it's right.</p><p>Meet your new multitasking essential. This clean 2-in-1 formula works as both a tinted moisturizer and a foundation. One layer delivers sheer, breathable hydration with a natural tint; two layers build to smooth, foundation-level coverage. Skincare-infused and non-comedogenic, it supports evolving skin while leaving a fresh, radiant finish that looks like your skin, only better.</p>
<p style="margin-top:16px;"><strong>Not sure which shade is right for you?</strong> <a href="https://puzzlemakeup.com/products/the-overachiever-custom-blend" title="The Overachiever Custom Blend">Try our Custom Blend</a> - one of our expert estheticians will mix your perfect match.</p>

How To Use

<p>Shake well before use. Because the formula is clean and silicone-free, slight separation is completely normal.</p>
<p><strong>For a tinted moisturizer finish</strong> (sheer, skin-like coverage): dispense a small amount (one pump or dime-sized) and apply one layer with your fingers, or for best results use our <a href="https://puzzlemakeup.com/products/wedge-sponge" target="_blank">Latex-Free Wedge Sponge</a>. Blend outward from the center of your face using gentle stroking motions. Allow the formula to set for a few seconds — the shade will adjust to its true tone.</p>
<p><strong>For a foundation finish</strong> (buildable coverage): let the first layer settle for 30–60 seconds, then gently apply a second layer throughout. Allow it to set for a few seconds and the shade will fully adjust.</p>
<p><em><strong>Pro tip:</strong> Use gentle stroking motions for a flawless, even finish. Start with less product and build as needed. Pair with <a href="https://puzzlemakeup.com/products/face-powder" target="_blank">Puzzle Pressed Powder</a> for a more polished, long-lasting result.</em></p>
<p><em><strong>Sponge guide:</strong> Thin side → thicker appearance. Thick side → thinner appearance.</em></p>

Size

0.3 oz | 8.5 g

Ingredient benefits

<p>Every Puzzle product is infused with skin-loving ingredients, but this 2-in-1 is an absolute skincare powerhouse. It boosts hydration and strengthens the skin barrier, supports collagen and elasticity for healthier-looking skin, brightens and evens tone for a radiant complexion, and delivers lightweight, breathable wear that feels comfortable all day.</p>

<ul>
<li><strong>Plant-based oils &amp; fatty acids:</strong> hydrate, soften, and support elasticity with lightweight, non-comedogenic moisture.</li>
<li><strong>Pomegranate extract:</strong> rich in vitamin C and polyphenols to brighten, even tone, and support collagen.</li>
<li><strong>Tea extracts (white, green &amp; black):</strong> antioxidant-rich botanicals that defend against free radicals, soothe sensitivity, and help maintain firmness.</li>
<li><strong>Vitamin E:</strong> protects from environmental damage, locks in moisture, and softens the look of fine lines.</li>
<li><strong>Sugarcane-derived emollients:</strong> deliver a silky, breathable texture that hydrates without heaviness.</li>
<li><strong>Performance-enhancing naturals:</strong> coconut- and corn-derived emulsifiers blend seamlessly, while mineral-based powders improve spreadability, absorb excess oil, and create a smooth, soft-focus finish.</li>
</ul>

Full Ingredients List

Water (Aqua), Dicaprylyl Carbonate, Polyglyceryl-2-Dipolyhydroxystearate, Hexyl Laurate, Mica, Butylene Glycol, Polyglyceryl-3-Diisostearate, Undecane, Propanediol, Pentaerythrityl Distearate, Sodium Chloride, Boron Nitride, Stearalkonium Hectorite, Potassium Cetyl Phosphate, Tridecane, Hydroxyacetophenone, Propylene Carbonate, Tocopheryl Acetate (vitamin E), Niacinamide, Lauroyl Lysine, Sodium Hyaluronate, Glycerin, Punica Granatum (Pomegranate) Extract, Camellia Sinensis (White Tea) Leaf Extract. May Contain: Iron Oxide CI 77492, Titanium Dioxide CI 77891, Iron Oxide CI 77499, Iron Oxide CI 77491, Chromium Hydroxide Green Cl 77289, Ultramarine Blue CI 77007.

✓ 100% Clean  ✓ Vegan  ✓ Multi-Use  ✓ Ideal For Mature Skin  ✓ Buildable  ✓ Lightweight  ✓ Long-Lasting  ✓ Skincare Benefits  ✓ Silicon-Free  ✓ Paraben-Free  ✓ Cruelty-Free  ✓ Fragrance-Free

YOUR REAL RESULTS WITH

The OVERACHIEVER

“
Twenty-three years ago, I made a decision: skin always comes first. The Overachiever is that decision, bottled. One layer delivers the hydration and glow of a tinted moisturizer. Two layers build to true foundation-level coverage. Skincare-infused. Non-comedogenic. Formulated for evolving, hormonal, rosacea-prone, and menopausal skin. This is what makeup should have always been.
”
Avital Signature

Avital Elgaziel

PUZZLE FOUNDER, EXPERT ESTHETICIAN & MAKEUP ARTIST

Avital Elgaziel
video

Powerhouse INGREDIENTS

Plant-Based Oils & Fatty Acids

Lightweight Hydration + Elasticity Support

Pomegranate Extract

Brightens Tone + Supports Collagen

Tea Extracts

Antioxidant Protection + Calming Care

Vitamin E

Barrier Protection + Moisture Retention

Sugarcane-Derived Emollients

Silky, Breathable Hydration

Performance-Driven Naturals

Seamless Blend + Soft-Focus Finish

For A Tinted Moisturizer Finish

(Sheer, Skin-Like Coverage)

Dispense a small amount (one pump or dime-sized) and apply one layer with your fingers, or for best results, use the Latex-Free Wedge Sponge. Blend outward from the center of your face using gentle stroking motions. Allow the formula to set for a few seconds - the shade will adjust to its true tone.

For A Foundation Finish

(Buildable Coverage)

Let the first layer settle for 30–60 seconds, then gently apply a second layer throughout. Allow it to set for a few seconds, and the shade will fully adjust.

Avital's Pro Tip

Use gentle stroking motions for a flawless, even finish. Start with less product and build as needed. Pair with Puzzle Pressed Powder for a more polished, long-lasting result.

Sponge Guide

Thin side → thicker appearance. Thick side → thinner appearance.

Love For THE OVERACHIEVER

“I am so excited about this product! I have very sensitive skin that is prone to redness/inflammation/rosacea so I've always shied away from foundation for fear of irritating my skin. I gave this product a try since it is also a moisturizer and I couldn't be happier with it. It actually feels good on my skin while also giving enough coverage to even out the redness. And it lasts all day, amazing!”

— Emily

“I'm an outdoors type of woman, very active and not into heavy makeup. I have a lot of red undertones and have tried all sorts of foundations from department stores and Sephora, trying to find a light foundation to even out my skin. Then I found Avital and Puzzle Makeup! Avital mixes my foundation exactly to fit my skin color and keeps the redness under control for the entire day. It's perfect! I highly recommend making a consultation appointment with Avital and letting her work her magic on you, too. You'll love your look!”

— Susan

“After trying SO many tinted moisturizers and foundations, I've finally found THE ONE. I have combination skin and have struggled to find something that's not too matte and looks dewy without getting greasy — this totally nails it. One light layer is perfect for everyday when I just want a natural, healthy glow with light coverage (while effectively evening skin tone, mind you), and two layers build into full coverage for more polished occasions without ever feeling cakey. It wears beautifully! Avital custom-matched my color, and I was a little skeptical at first as it looked a bit gray before applying, but it's actually the PERFECT shade.”

— Kat

“When I say I've tried a LOT of tinted moisturizers, I mean it. For 20+ years, it's been one of two things you're sure to find in my makeup bag (mascara = #2). I rate them on 1) how clean the ingredients are, 2) how they feel on my skin, and 3) how they look. The Overachiever checks all my boxes and then some. I just love that I can swipe on a single layer for everyday wear and put on a second layer for more coverage - both ways it feels and looks great. Add in Puzzle's mission and story, and what's not to love?”

— Lauren

“Puzzle custom-mixed foundation is amazing! It is blended to match perfectly with your unique skin tone, and it provides great coverage. Since my skin is acne-prone, I really appreciate that the foundation is clean and doesn't cause breakouts or irritation. I highly recommend it!”

— Aviva

“I've worn the same high-end department store foundation for years. I had no problem with it, but my friend suggested I try Puzzle Makeup. I thought I would give it a try. I'm not a fan of the "mineral makeup" that was popular for a while. I found it too drying and dull on my skin. Puzzle foundation is amazingly light, creamy, and gives a beautiful luminescence to the skin. They will mix it up just for you and can match it exactly to your skin tone. The face powder also feels so good on my skin and creates a beautiful finish. Love it! I won't go back.”

— Annette

“Puzzle Makeup has completely changed the way I feel about wearing makeup. I've been amazed at how effortlessly the foundation blends into my skin, enhancing my natural beauty instead of covering it up. The formula feels incredibly light, like I'm wearing nothing at all - yet the results are flawless. I've never had so many compliments on my complexion! I'm officially obsessed.”

— Laura

Overall rating: 4.925373 / 5 from 67 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

This 2-in-1 tinted moisturizer and foundation offers sheer, breathable hydration with a natural tint. It provides smooth coverage, a flawless finish, and is non-toxic, oil-free, and non-comedogenic. Customers appreciate its lightweight feel, natural look, and clean ingredients.

Summary topics

  • Finish (11%): Customers appreciated the flawless and skin-like finish of the product, making it perfect for everyday wear.
  • Skin Feel (11%): Customers keep praising how the product makes their skin feel soft, hydrated, and more comfortable.
  • Coverage (19%): Many customers appreciated that the product provides great coverage without looking too heavy or thick, making it a popular choice.
  • Makeup Quality (21%): Based on a significant number of customers, the makeup is highly praised for its clean ingredients and fantastic customer service.
  • Skin Health (19%): In general, customers found the foundation to be non-toxic, oil-free, noncomedogenic, and non-irritating.

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

  • "Now after I wash my face, my skin feels so soft and hydrated - it's amazing!" — Karan H.
  • "The face powder feels so good on my skin and crates a beautiful finish." — Annette
  • "My skin instantly looks smoother, more even, and naturally radiant�never cakey or heavy." — Angela L.

Reviews

My go to product for my roseaca

"I saw a spot for puzzle makeup online somewhere and liked how they presented the product. I have had roseaca since covid and I’m a 78 year old woman. It has been a challenge and I didn’t think that anything I have put on my skin to calm it down has worked. I decided to try it. I know use it as my moisturizer with a second coverage as my daily makeup. For most days it keeps my cheek from flaring and becoming red and hot! It’s not perfect on some days and I have flare ups! I feel like I have a new tool to use instead of 3 separate products that didn’t work! Many thanks to the Puzzle creators for getting this out to us! Kathy Baxter"

— Kathy S. (4/5)

Custom blend overachiever

"I wanted something that won’t irritate my already irritated, sensitive skin. Also a bonus because I don’t need to apply moisturizer or concealer. Applications is quick and easy. Love the natural look too."

— Kandy L. (5/5)

Puzzle coverage

"I love the coverage of this makeup and moisturizer. Face feels great It is also non irritating"

— Kim T. (5/5)

Decades search for coverage is over!

"I am 55 and have had rosacea my entire life. I spent almost three decades trying everything including lazers, chemicals, cleansers, prescription and non creams, toners, peels,etc. I saw women on your advertisement with REAL redness and how the Overachiever helped them so I prayed it wasn’t fake and ordered a custom blend. I am beyond ecstatic that this works and that I finally look normal! I also have seborrhea and I have not had any issues with this make up. I absolutely will be buying more. Thank you so much to Melisa who perfected my color and to whoever invented this, I love you!"

— UpstateNY (5/5)

Amazing!

"I'm always on the hunt for a foundation, or tinted moisturizer, that does not contain silicones (makes me break out badly) and helps cover my moderate rosacea, and this popped up on my Instagram. I didn't know what color to get, so I sent a photo, and I ordered the shade recommended: Jasmine. At first, the color was a bit jarring - how is this going to cover my redness? It's gray?! But after I blended it in, I wanted to cry; it was that perfect. To find a low-maintenance product that moisturizes, covers my redness, evens my skintone, looks great all day, and is made without silicones!?!? Are you kidding me? This is perfection, and I am a fan for life! I will definitely repurchase!"

— Helen G. (5/5)

It is way too grayish

"It is way too grayish in color, so I can't use it all over my face. So instead I use it first on top of & to cover my rosacea & then apply either the light or medium Overachievers over those areas & lightly over the rest of my face, which is ok for everyday coverage."

— Kathy B. (3/5)

Best yet

"I have tried so many different foundations, BB cream, CC creams, and tinted moisturizers. From high end, to grocery stores, I have tried 100s. My skin is very dry from tretinoin use, but still oily as well. Other foundations are just too drying on my skin. CC creams and BB creams don't have enough coverage and are also drying. Tinted moisturizers make my skin too oily. This Puzzle makeup is perfect. Glides on without pilling, looks natural without being too matte, and I do not look shiny. As someone else stated, I was worried because the color I was sent looks gray, but it matches perfect."

— Tracy (5/5)

Great makeup and fantastic customer service

"I ordered the overachiever during a particularly serious rosacea flare up. This is the best product I have tried for cancelling redness. No green or grey cast like other products can leave. The finish looks like skin. I reached out to customer service when it looked like the shipping company might be late, because I was anxious to cover the flare up. Amber responded quickly, and reached out to the shipping company. She kept me in the loop on the status, and it did arrive on time. She has since gone on to discuss the overachiever and how it was working, what else she may be able to help me with, etc. Above and beyond and overall awesome customer service! Heartily recommend Puzzle and its products!"

— Jennifer (5/5)

Amazing product

"I am so excited about this product! I have very sensitive skin that is prone to redness/inflammation/rosacea so I've always shied away from foundation for fear of irritating my skin. I gave this product a try since it is also a moisturizer and I couldn't be happier with it. It actually feels good on my skin while also giving enough coverage to even out the redness. And it lasts all day, amazing!"

— Emily (5/5)

Best customized foundation!

"I really appreciate the unique option to have my foundation customized by Avital! Practically impossible for me to discern which shade to choose. The foundation stays fresh looking during the day, coverage is smooth & shade looks natural on my face. I would update this foundation each year. Highly recommended -- you will adore!"

— Hilda L. (5/5)

Q&A

Build Your Own BUNDLE

SAVE 10%
Makeup products including a lip gloss and blushes with 'PUZZLE' branding on a light gray background.

The Daily Look

FRESH EVERYDAY BEAUTY

add to bag · $83.70
Customize
SAVE 15%

The Romance Edition

SOFT + DREAMY HUES

add to bag · $124.53
Customize
SAVE 15%
Boss Mode Kit from Puzzle® Makeup featuring a collection of vibrant cosmetics including matte eyeshadows, blush, lipstick, and highlighter in elegant packaging. Perfect for creating bold and confident looks.

Boss Mode Kit

AM TO PM PIGMENTS

add to bag · $142.38
Customize
SAVE 20%

Sexy Glam Kit

ICONIC SULTRY SHADES

add to bag · $158.00
Customize
SAVE 20%

Effortless Beauty Bundle

FOR ANY OCCASION

add to bag · $210.40
Customize
SAVE 20%

The Rule Breakers Set

DARE TO STAND OUT

add to bag · $274.00
Customize

Join Us → @PUZZLEMAKEUP

Everyday routines, visible results, pro tips from Avital, and a community that gets it.